After testing more self-tanners than I can count—definitely over a dozen I've narrowed down the three that still earn a spot in my bathroom cabinet.

Each one has something different to offer, from application style to the final color payoff.

1. Tanologist Express Self-Tan Water

This formula continues to impress me. Because it applies clear, there's zero worry about staining sheets or clothing. It feels light on the skin, dries quickly, and doesn't carry that heavy "tanner" scent. The end result is a smooth, believable bronze with no hint of orange. For the performance and finish, it's absolutely worth the price.

2. Jergens Self-Tanning Mousse

This one is solid but not a personal favorite. The tinted formula makes it easy to see where you apply it, but it also means you have to be careful to avoid streaks. It has a stronger scent and tends to lean a touch warm on my skin tone. Still, it provides an even tan and is a great wallet-friendly option if you want color without splurging.

3. Jergens Self-Tanning Lotion for Wet Skin

When convenience matters, this is the one I reach for. You smooth it onto damp skin right after showering, which makes it almost effortless. It doesn't transfer onto clothing, it has a mild scent, and the color develops into a soft, natural bronze with barely any orange. Perfect for nights when you want a little glow without the fuss.

These three self-tanners each have their strengths, whether it's the natural bronze from Tanologist, the affordability of Jergens mousse, or the convenience of Jergens wet-skin lotion. Choosing the right one depends on personal preference, but all three make achieving a sun-kissed look simple and enjoyable!